I think this article is very true however when you are living through a time like this in history it is hard for us to realize what is going on. Large scale political changes take years, decades, and unfortunately sometimes a century to come to fruition. I hope those at the mid point in our lives get a chance to see the positive effects of a death of liberalism.
TUSC
________________________________________________________________________
Bob Tyrrell was right.
The founder of
The American Spectator penned — in
2011, two years ago —
The Death of Liberalism.
In which Tyrrell investigated “the decline and impending death
of the American Liberal movement in the United States today.” And
said of President Obama that he was a “Stealth Fascist” who was
“the pallbearer for American Liberalism.”
Notably, the last chapter of the book was titled:
President
Barack Obama, Liberalism’s Pallbearer. With considerable
prescience, Mr. Tyrrell begins the chapter thusly:
Chairman Mao made the following statement on April 30, 1971, to
Edgar Snow in an interview that he hoped would reach the ears of
American policymakers. In it he said:
“China should learn from the way America developed, by
decentralizing and spreading responsibility and wealth among the 50
states. A central government could not do everything. China must
depend upon regional and local initiative. It would not do
(spreading his hands) to leave everything up to him (Mao).”
Forty years later, China was on the brink of becoming the
world’s largest economy, and President Barack Obama had not a clue
about learning “from the way America developed” or about depending
on its “regional and local initiatives.” He was lost in the sublime
quiddities of his incomparable colleagues from the Ruling Class.
That would be the yokels back at academe, drunk on their higher
knowledge of “how-to” studies: how to teach (education
departments), how to think and analyze (psychology and sociology
departments), how to administer and govern (variations of the John
F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard State University) — all
the trendy “studies” offered by the modern-day multiversity or
whatever they call it. Obama does not have very many classically
educated university graduates to call on. In fact, he does not have
many educated people to call on.
Think of that.
The Great Leader of the Chinese Communist Party saying 42 years
ago that “a central government could not do everything.” And that
was 20 years before the Soviet Union, its centralized
administrative planning and command economy imploding, finally did
one last stagger and crashed onto the ash heap of history — as
Ronald Reagan predicted was inevitable.
Just as Tyrrell predicted, Obama and company, believing the
opposite and in denial over the reality of the Soviet lesson, made
Obamacare the very face of “Friendly Fascism” and “Stealth
Fascism.” Today the entire Great Leap Forward in American health
care as envisioned by the liberal “yokels back at academe, drunk on
their higher knowledge of ‘how-to’ studies” is a disaster
collapsing in on itself faster than a Florida sinkhole.
All at once, the reality of the collective consequences of
liberalism is glaringly in the spotlight — making Tyrrell’s point
with an uncanny precision.
The worship of Big Government? The laughably arrogant
“we-know-what’s-best-for-you” sense of moral and intellectual
superiority? These “smart” people can’t even run a website. The
eternal liberal dependence on class warfare and racism? Yes indeed,
the party of slavery, segregation, lynching, the Ku Klux Klan,
racial quotas and illegal immigration never blinked at the shameful
firing of an Obamacare operator — a black single mom — for the
“crime” of answering Sean Hannity’s questions honestly. And doing
so while keeping on a rich white woman named Kathleen Sebelius
whose management of Obamacare has been as incompetent as it is
dishonest. Sebelius, the privileged white liberal daughter of a
white liberal governor and a white liberal governor herself,
acceded to the firing of Erling Davis, the black single mother
whose only sin was answering Hannity’s questions and with no spin.
Hannity, appalled, quickly re-contacted Davis and is picking up
the tab for her year’s salary as well as finding her a job. “Are
you surprised Kathleen Sebelius still has her job and you got fired
for doing yours?” Hannity asked of Davis when he had her on his Fox
TV show. To which Davis replied: “Yes sir.”
Well aside from the volumes this incident says about Hannity’s
character, the incident speaks volumes about the core nature of
liberalism itself and its dependence on both the sheerest, most
blatant thuggery combined with a thick veneer of out-and-out
racism. Which in turn goes directly to Tyrrell’s point that in
reality Obama himself is turning out to be the pallbearer for a
philosophy that is in fact unsustainable.
From one end of America to the other, some 16 million Americans
are estimated to be losing their health insurance policies because
of Obamacare. The
Weekly Standard’s John McCormack leads
us to health care expert Bob Laszewski, who
writes:
The U.S. individual health insurance market currently totals
about 19 million people. Because the Obama administration’s
regulations on grandfathering existing plans were so stringent as
many as 16 million are not grandfathered and must comply with
Obamacare at their next renewal. The rules are very complex. For
example, if you had an individual plan in March of 2010 when the
law was passed and you only increased the deductible from $1,000 to
$1,500 in the years since, your plan has lost its grandfather
status and it will no longer be available to you when it would have
renewed in 2014.
Over at Kaiser Health News the reporting
says:
Health plans are sending hundreds of thousands of cancellation
letters to people who buy their own coverage, frustrating some
consumers who want to keep what they have and forcing others to buy
more costly policies.
… An estimated 14 million people purchase their own coverage
because they don’t get it through their jobs. Calls to insurers in
several states showed that many have sent notices.
Florida Blue, for example, is terminating about 300,000
policies, about 80 percent of its individual policies in the state.
Kaiser Permanente in California has sent notices to 160,000 people
— about half of its individual business in the state. Insurer
Highmark in Pittsburgh is dropping about 20 percent of its
individual market customers, while Independence Blue Cross, the
major insurer in Philadelphia, is dropping about 45 percent.
In Laszewski’s words? “This is a fine mess.”
Indeed.
Which brings us back to Bob Tyrrell and his sharp-eyed analysis
on
The Death of Liberalism. Tyrrell cites a figure offered
up by Arthur Brooks of the American Enterprise Institute in Brooks’
own book
The Battle, Tyrrell saying:
Conservatism has steadily spread throughout the Republic since
its larval days in the 1950’s, and Liberalism has declined to its
present need for a proper burial.
The reason is that the vast majority of Americans favor free
enterprise and personal liberty. Arthur Brooks of the American
Enterprise Institute, in his book, The Battle, offers a
figure that roughly approximates other studies:70 percent of
Americans who favor free enterprise and personal liberty versus 30
percent of Americans who do not favor such freedom.
Time after time in American history political arguments are made
to seem ephemeral — until, with massive impact, they slam into the
body politic with the force of a vast and violent tornado. Debates
about slavery were just that for millions of Americans — until the
abrupt arrival of the Civil War. Millions of American families were
directly and permanently affected by the sea of clashing blue and
gray armies that left behind one battlefield after another strewn
with the brutalized dead bodies of over 600,000 husbands, sons and
brothers. Likewise the distant voices of Adolf Hitler and Japanese
war lords were nothing more than radio rantings and newsreel
footage — until Pearl Harbor and the explosion of World War II.
Over 400,000 Americans died on far away beaches, jungles and
oceans, changing America and Americans forever.
Political change isn’t always about violence, either. The rise
of the automobile and interstate highways, cable TV, talk radio and
the computer, to name but four, brought sweeping change to America
and its political habits. And in each instance they have in their
own way, as Tyrrell notes, steadily spread conservatism throughout
the Republic.
Now comes the utter disaster that is Obamacare. What once was a
political debate mostly attracting the attention of activists is
now slamming into the everyday lives of millions, as both Kaiser
and Laszewski have documented. As with the Civil War or World War
II and the other agents of change, Obamacare is having a political
impact — and a big one.
The other day, the
Wall Street Journal’s Kimberly
Strassel in a must-read column titled “Democrats Run for ObamaCare
Cover”
wrote:
Jeanne Shaheen doesn’t sound like a Democrat who just won a
government-shutdown “victory.” Ms. Shaheen sounds like a Democrat
who thinks she’s going to lose her job.
The New Hampshire senator fundamentally altered the health-care
fight on Tuesday with a letter to the White House demanding it both
extend the ObamaCare enrollment deadline and waive tax penalties
for those unable to enroll. Within nanoseconds, Arkansas Sen. Mark
Pryor had endorsed her “common-sense idea.” By Wednesday night,
five Senate Democrats were on board, pushing for… what’s that dirty
GOP word? Oh, right. “Delay.”
After 16 long days of vowing to Republicans that they would not
cave in any way, shape or form on ObamaCare, Democrats spent their
first post-shutdown week caving in every way, shape and form. With
the GOP’s antics now over, the only story now is the unrivaled
disaster that is the president’s health-care law.
Strassel went on to note the problem causing this wave of panic
among Democrats:
Hundreds of thousands of health-insurance policies canceled.
Companies dumping coverage and cutting employees’ hours. Premiums
skyrocketing. And a website that reprises the experience of a
Commodore 64. As recently as May, Democratic consultants were
advising members of Congress that their best ObamaCare strategy for
2014 was to “own” the law. Ms. Shaheen has now publicly advised the
consultants where they can file that memo.
What Strassel is describing here is the real world political
effect of what Tyrrell described as (bold print for emphasis
added):
Liberalism’s distinctive trait: overreach. At times Liberals
promise too much. At times they attempt too much.
Occasionally they actually achieve too much, leaving many
Americans fearing for their liberties and the contents of their
wallets.
The Obamacare overreach is nothing if not a story of lost
liberty (promises you can keep your doctor are up in smoke) and the
contents of American wallets are being emptied to pay for
skyrocketing premiums.
The Civil War produced an unbroken string of Republican
presidents, broken only twice — in 1884 and 1892 — by the
election and non-consecutive re-election of Democrat Grover
Cleveland. Not until 1912 was another Democrat allowed inside the
White House as occupant — the war producing 44 years’ worth of GOP
presidents. World War II steamrollered considerable pre-war
isolationist sentiments, with every Democrat and Republican
presidential candidate from 1944 on until Democrat George
McGovern’s anti-Vietnam War candidacy in 1972 producing
internationalist candidates on both sides.
The automobile mass production of Henry Ford combined with the
later interstate highway system of Dwight Eisenhower to speed up
the move of millions into what we now call the suburbs — and
giving conservative candidates a boost as the American population
shifted from the urban Northeast to the South and West, producing
the presidencies of Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan and both Bushes.
Cable TV birthed Fox News, which, combined with the advent of talk
radio, broke the Left’s media monopoly. And, of course, the arrival
of the Internet has changed everything in terms of how politics is
discussed and money raised for candidates both Left and Right.
Obamacare is hitting the American Left with another body blow.
To some this is doubtless ironic, not unlike Frankenstein turning
on his creator. Yet the real question is simple: how else could
Obamacare possibly have turned out?
There is no accident that Mark Levin’s books
Liberty and Tyranny,
Ameritopia, and the recently released
Liberty Amendments have not only soared to the top of
bestseller lists but made a major impact across the country with
the Tea Party and well beyond into the halls of Congress and state
legislatures. These books are the tip of the intellectual spear
that are providing the grounding for the rising tide against not
simply Obamacare but the larger move to reject the nation’s
founding principles of liberty and freedom in a last desperate
drive to socialize America, to make statism the real American
religion.
In his book, Tyrrell cited this from Victor Davis Hanson, a
senior fellow at the Hoover Institution who was writing in
National Review Online on July 4, 2011:
Here in the United States, we await the imposition of ObamaCare,
despite the fact that the public does not want it, the nation
cannot afford it, politicians regret it, and companies seek
exemption from it. Our current pace of $1.6 trillion annual
deficits, for all the talk of Keynesian gymnastics, is
unsustainable — and even acknowledged as such by those who are
most responsible for the latest round of fiscal irresponsibility.
As we near fifty million Americans on food stamps, another year of
9-plus percent unemployment , and the third $1 trillion-plus budget
deficit, even statists are beginning to see that statism does not
work.
Tyrrell thought that last line was a bit over the top, yet two
years later the sight of frantic Democrats running to keep from
being run over by Obamacare as Strassel and others have noted is
nothing if not a confirmation of both Tyrrell and Hanson. In fact,
Hanson’s mention of “9-plus percent unemployment” understates.
While the unemployment rate is technically listed at 7.2%, in fact,
as is
noted in
Forbes back in July:
But the “official” unemployment rate doesn’t count men and women
like G. — discouraged workers who have settled for part-time jobs
or have given up looking altogether. Tracking those individuals,
under what’s called the “U-6″ rate, gives a very different measure
of the nation’s unemployment rate: 14.3%.
There are political consequences for things like this. The
mistake too many people make is that in seeing no political
consequences pop immediately in this or that election, they ignore
the looming disaster that — whether it takes years or decades to
appear — eventually and inevitably does hit. Debates over slavery
had been ongoing since the Constitution was approved in 1787 — a
full 74 years passing before the Civil War erupted at Ft. Sumter in
April of 1861. A full two decades — plus had passed between the
end of World War I and the attack on Pearl Harbor. These changes do
not occur overnight. But when they arrive, they can change the
country so thoroughly Americans find themselves looking backwards
in wonder at a country they once knew well and no longer
exists.
Tyrrell runs the list of progressive entitlement programs and
their mind-bending costs speeding the country to bankruptcy.
Medicare, estimated at its start to cost “no more than $12 billion
by 1990” — and in fact cost $110 billion. Medicaid — $4 billion
in 1966, $41 billion in 1986, $423 billion in 2010. All of this
before one counts entitlements like public housing, food stamps,
day care, home-heating assistance, sex therapy, and more — all
unfunded.”
Collectively, this has left the United States with a $17
trillion debt and almost $90 trillion in unfunded liabilities.
An entitlement disaster looms, in the
words of Harvard’s Niall Ferguson in the
Wall Street
Journal — and Mr. Ferguson is right.
Which brings us back to Bob Tyrrell and the
Death of
Liberalism.
It may have taken eight decades, but the self-destructiveness of
what Tyrrell called a “strange and meretricious ideology” that was
once quaintly labeled as “tax and spend” liberalism is finally
overtaking its obsessive utopian addicts. “The nation has arrived
at a great reckoning,” he wrote.
The tidal wave approaches, with Obamacare the leading edge of
the wave.
And when it crashes, it will swamp American liberalism, with
major political consequences.
Of which the Death of Liberalism will almost certainly be
one.